Love Your Competition!
by Patricia
Luebke
Patricia Luebke is a New York-based marketing
consultant
with more than 20 years magazine publishing experience.
Pat conducts sales training seminars, conducts
market
research, produces promotional materials and provides
strategic planning and media relations assistance.
She may be reached at 212-996-1409..
Competition
is good for you
You may mutter
expletives about your competition or blame most
of your gray hair on them. You may fantasize about
how wonderful -- or easy -- your business life
would be if your competition closed their doors.
But did you ever think about how your competition
helps you? That's right. Your competition does
good things for you. Instead of thinking of your
competition as a drain on your time and energy
(not to mention your customer base), start thinking
of all the good things your competition does for
you. Be grateful for how hard your competition
is working on your behalf.
Niches
Your competition
creates market niches for you. For example, if
your competition is a magazine serving the powerboat
market, the sailboat market is left to you. If
you compete with an award-winning advertising
agency who is behind the power curve in their
understanding of websites and other means of electronic
communication, that agency is ceding that business
to you. Whatever your competition doesn't --or
won't -- do is available as your company's specialty.
Instead of going head-to-head against a competitor
for the same market segment, you might consider
a strategy where you fill a niche your competition
doesn't cover.
Leads
Your competition
provides a source of new customers. We're not
suggesting stealing customers, but a competitor's
unhappy customers will find their way to you.
You are getting customers who are ready to buy,
who want to buy, who would welcome the first-class
treatment you can provide. You may even get a
chance with your own former customers who leave
you for the competition only to return when they
realized how good they had it with you.
Compared to
them. . .
Your competition
can make you look good. A competitor's unprofessional
behavior, failure to meet a deadline or exceeding
an agreed-upon budget can all serve to boost your
own company's image. Your understanding of and
involvement with a particular special interest
market segment will come through loud and clear
when compared to your competition's generalist
talents. Your customers are weighing you against
your competition, and you can come out on top.
Whatever they do badly, you can do well. Whatever
weak points they have can become your strengths.
Their mistakes
You can learn
from your competition's mistakes. Your competition
has a trade show booth that can only be described
as silly. Your competition tries a pricing plan
that makes customers leave them and come to you.
Your competition aligns itself with a company
with a poor reputation. Your competition attempts
to reposition itself and does it badly. That's
when you start taking notes. Watch what your competition
does and learn from their mistakes. Your competition
keeps you sharp and motivated. No matter which
side of the desk you are on -- as media seller
or media buyer -- your clients have choices. This
knowledge continually guides you to try to improve
the quality of your own customer service and support.
Providing your customers with better service,
quicker service or more cost-efficient service
is easier to do when there is competition nipping
at your heels. Without your competition, it would
be easy to get complacent in your business practices.
Competition is good for everybody, especially
the customer.
"Borrowing"
Your competition
gives you ideas you can... steal. Well, maybe
not steal. Your competition gives you ideas you
can adapt for your own use. That's why it's important
for you to keep an eye on your competition. For
example, if you are monitoring where your competition
is advertising and see that they have stayed in
Ad Age, for example, over a long
period of time, it's a pretty safe bet that the
publication is working for them and may work equally
well for you, too. If you're a media rep and a
competitor's new media kit has been mentioned
to you for the third time by an agency media buyer,
you'd be wise to get a hold of the kit and see
why it's so good. Does a new tagline for a competitive
magazine easily position them in media buyers'
minds? There's nothing wrong with analyzing what
your competition has done and adapting it for
your own company.
Better than
who?
Your competition
is a yardstick for your own market position. How
can you claim to be #1 in your market without
your competition filling the spots for #2 on down?
If you're the leading advertising agency for the
travel industry, you're only a market leader as
long as there are market followers. Conversely,
if you are competing against the #1 company or
magazine, you have something to aim for. For example,
Avis built an entire company around their #2 market
position. Further, you can judge how your sales
are doing by comparing them to the competition.
Whether it's in number of customers, a particular
dollar volume of sales or the prestige value of
your customers, your competition helps you measure
your own success. Former New York Mayor Ed Koch
was known for asking his constituents, "How am
I doing?" and that's a question your competition
helps you answer as well.
Staffing source
Your competition
provides a source of employees. We bet that you
have at least one employee on staff who used to
work for your competition. In fact, there are
few people employed within the media industry
who have not worked at competitive media or rival
ad agencies. Your competition is a good source
of new hires for you. When you hire someone who
works for your competition, that new employee
brings a wealth of information and expertise to
you. If you know him (or her) by his reputation,
you're taking less of a risk with a new employee,
knowing that you are hiring a known quantity.
One word of caution: Some employees are required
to sign "no compete" contracts in which they promise
that they will not work for the competition if
they leave their place of employment. Some of
these contracts have been upheld in court; others
haven't. Make sure you check this out with your
own legal counsel before hiring someone from a
competitor.
Where are you
working next year?
Your competition
provides employment opportunities. Of course,
the street runs two ways. If you're an employee
and not the owner of a company, your competition
is the most likely place for you to seek employment
as well. Your reputation as a creative person,
as a salesperson or as a media analyst is being
noted not just by your own employer and customers,
but by your competition as well. This is another
good reason to conduct yourself with dignity with
your competition. Badmouthing the competition
can quickly backfire. What's more, crow doesn't
taste so good. In the media business, you never
know what company name may be on your next paycheck.
Competitive
spirit
Your competition
makes business more fun. This is the best thing
your competition does for you. Admit it: playing
the game of chess with your competition is fun.
Having a competitor you "love to hate" makes coming
to work worthwhile. When you institute a program
that brings in new business or win a major client
over from your competition, the victory is all
the more sweet when it comes at the expense of
your favorite competitor.
If you can't
join 'em, beat 'em!
Competition
is a fact of business life. Don't neglect your
competition, but rather use your competition to
your advantage by being aware of what they are
doing, whether in their product line, sales and
service or their own marketing. All of this market
intelligence can be done through totally ethical
methods. For example, you can learn a great deal
about your competition by scrutinizing their advertising
or media kit or agency profile. You can learn
about your competition from the vendors who call
on both of you. (Bear in mind, though, that if
a vendor is telling you about a competitor, he
is likely telling a competitor about you, too.)
You can learn through more informal channels such
as the word-of-mouth generated by your customers
and employees. All of this input should be analyzed
by you to take the market temperature of your
competition.
Ahead of the
game
Why study
your competition? You need to know as much as
you can so that your competition doesn't upstage
you. You need to make course corrections in your
own business plan. You need to be able to respond
covertly or overtly to what they are saying. You
need to know as much as you can about your competition
so that you can plan your own strategy for healthy
and profitable business.
And, finally,
you need to know as much as you can about your
competition because the marketplace can be fickle.
You may be in a solid #l position in your market
today, but you have no guarantee what the future
holds for you.
Win by leading
However, marketing
your own company -- minding your own business
-- must come first. Don't make the mistake of
getting so involved in one-upping the competition
that you ignore your own business. The best way
to keep a few steps ahead of your competition
-- whether big or small -- is to have marketing
programs in place which embrace three factors:
constancy, longevity and involvement.
You may not
love your competition, but it will serve your
business to understand your competition and make
the competitive atmosphere work for you. Understanding
the role your competition has in your business
will make you a much more savvy marketing strategist.
And that can only mean more business for you.